dream-come-true gone wrong. Well, Una asked for it. She wanted
suitors, and suitors she's got. Her newest one being the completely awful Duke
of Shippening . . . perhaps the most un-nuanced (and yet one of the most
entertaining) characters in the entire novel. He's big. He's vulgar. He's far
too old. He's cruel. He's greedy. He's just absolutely everything you would NOT
want in a suitor. Not even Nurse, who at first thinks, "Hey, it's a duke!
Why not marry him?" is horrified
at the notion of her little charge ending up with such an oaf.
everyone must be polite. Shippening may not be a kingdom, and the duke may not be a king . . . but the Duchy of
Shippening includes Capaneus City, a vitally important trade city. I wish I
could show you a map, for it would explain just why. I've not yet drawn up an official map for my world, however, because
it is always growing. But there are some basics set in stone.
instance, Southlands is connected to the rest of the Continent by a thin isthmus.
On one side of the isthmus is Chiara Bay, and the on the other is the western
ocean. Capaneus City is built right on the end of that isthmus and controls all
trade between ships from the west and Chiara Bay. Neither Parumvir nor Beauclair
have eastern coasts, so any trading they want to do with the Far East, they
have to send their merchants waaaaaay down south, either sailing around
Southlands, or . . . putting in at Capaneus. Which means the Duke of Shippening
ultimately controls a vital link between these western kingdoms and all eastern
may not be a king, but the Duke of Shippening is sittin' pretty! Not a man you
want to offend.
I don't know if that was interesting to you or not. One day, I'll draw up a
final map, I promise! But probably not for another few books . . .
Una's Reaction. Una is, quite
naturally, horrified. I liked the description of her face mirroring the
expression of her bean-man tapestry, his mouth open in a silent scream. I always
find when I illustrate that my face takes on the expression of the character
I'm illustrating. I don't know why! I've caught myself, bent over the drafting
table, pencil in hand, my face contorted into the most frightful expression.
It's all unconscious (Do some of you artists do this? I hope I'm not the only
one who does!).
smiled when I read about Una doing the same thing. Yet another little way that
she inherited my own attributes!
The scene in the
story! So when I was reading along in this chapter, I fully expected to come
upon a scene between Una and Leonard . . . only set inside the house itself
while he cleaned windows! Oh, I expected the same conversation, just not out in
see this scene of Una meeting Leonard down by the Old Bridge was a rewrite
in one of the very last drafts of Heartless
before it went to print. For a good six or seven drafts before that, I'd had
them have this conversation inside. And that's where I still expect to see it,
remember I switched the location because I got so tired of the scene between
them. It felt really stale after a few rewrites, but it's full of important
moments. So I uprooted it and put it down by the Old Bridge, and it took on new
of course, if you've read Veiled Rose,
you know there's much more to this scene than meets the eye . . .
Remembering. Una thinks of
Aethelbald in this scene! To everyone who thinks she is totally indifferent to
him, I cry you mercy and beg you look upon this scene with a more careful eye!
Here it is five weeks later, and her thoughts still go back to him. Sure, she's
telling herself that he'll never come back, and she might even try to convince
herself that she's glad. But he's still there in her mind. And I'll bet he's a
little more deeply embedded in her heart than she might realize as well.
Leonard. But, ultimately
this scene is about Leonard. We've got some big revelations coming up about
him, and in this scene we get some set-up for them. We also get another chance
to see Leonard and Una together, to see the rapport they've developed, despite
the differences in their ranks and personalities.
definitely see how resentful Leonard is at being made to sweep and mop and
pursue other menial tasks. Which does seem a bit odd! He doesn't strike one,
at first glance, as being so very proud.
But he is proud. And he doesn't like for Una to imply that he is not her equal
. . . even though she is a princess, and
he is a jester.
he also regrets his sharpness with her right away and tries to make her laugh.
I think this scene demonstrates a number of conflicted emotions on his side! He
really cares about Una, wants to see her happy. But he feels so confined, so
perhaps he's just playing a game of his own . . .
A pity he's a
way or the other, after this exchange, we notice a sharp difference in Una's
attitude. Suddenly, she's comparing Gervais to Leonard, and the Prince of
Beauclair is coming up wanting. And Una even indulges, however briefly, in the
thought, A pity he's a jester.
feelings have shifted suddenly and--in typical Una fashion--very strongly into
a new avenue. And no matter how much she tells herself to stop, she does not
have so much control over her wayward heart as all that . . .
Enter the Duke. It is with the
arrival of Una's third and most obnoxious suitor that we begin to hear more
solid rumors of dragons and the fate of Southlands. Shippening is not very far
from Southlands, and the Dragon's smoke can easily be seen from Capaneus City.
learn from the duke that the Dragon is "looking to procreate." Not
quite the first thing you'd expect from a dragon, is it? But when Felix
questions further, wondering just how it is that dragons procreate, Fidel cuts
off the duke and won't let him speak anymore on this topic.
duke also tells us that the crown prince of Southlands, Lionheart, was killed by
Retired to the
sitting room. I
confess, I got a chuckle of the mental picture of the duke puffing pipe smoke
Una's way just to watch her cough. What a completely odious man! He's so over-the-top, which technically isn't very good
writing on my part. But I have to admit, I really love him! He's hilarious and
just so hideously villainous. Even though I know
better--I know that villains should have good qualities as well as bad to make
them fully fleshed-out--I don't think I'd change a thing on the Duke of
The Beastly Lout. Oh, great
Lights Above! The jester demonstrates tremendous gall by singing that horrible song to/about the duke.
And the duke appears to oblivious to the insult . . . though the rest of those
listening are not! In one moment of irritable jealousy and maddening
foolishness, Leonard the Lightning Tongue loses his job and is ordered by King
Fidel to pack his bags and leave.
to Una's dismay!
A revelation. Una, horrified,
makes a hasty getaway from the sitting room, following in the wake of the
jester . . . who is waiting for her, as it turns out. Interrupting poor Una in
the midst of one of her fumble-tongued tirades, he makes a stunning
declaration: "I am Prince Lionheart of Southlands."
1. Una paused with
her needle pulled partway through a bean man's eye. "The Duke of . . . But
Nurse, he's older than Father!"
sturdy age, practically the prime of life."
enough, anyway." (p.141)
romance seemed to have vanished from life in one fell swoop. She might as well
give it all up now and begin preparing herself for the role of spinster
princess of Parumvir--
That was my foot." (p. 142)
be silly," Una said.
be helped. It's my job." (p. 143)
what brings you down here, Princess Una?"
make it sound like the descending hordes. How many this time?" (p. 144)
I think you are a very brave Fool," Una said quietly.
I were not a Fool, do you think I could be brave?" (p. 146)
(Fidel) had received word that the duke wished to "pay his respects,"
his own heart had sunk--not so much for fear of losing his daughter to this
man, but because he'd known the duke since childhood, when they'd been obliged
to play together as noblemen's children should. He retained vivid memories of
being sat upon by the large boy which had not improved with time. (p. 148) Hahaha! Sounds like young Fidel had his own
set of adventures back in the day!
Questions on the
1. So, tell me
honestly . . . how many of you guessed Leonard's identity the moment you heard
the duke mention the supposed-dead crown prince Lionheart of Southlands?
2. When you first
read this novel, what were your thoughts on the mysterious rumors of dragons?
Could you guess how a dragon might procreate?
are your favorite lines?
1. "I have a question about Aethelbald's father, the High King. Will we meet him some time in a future book or is he always in the land of Farthestshore? Was the thrush the representative of the Holy Spirit?" -- Little Brown Sparrow
The High King beyond the Final Water will be mentioned throughout the various books. At this point, I don't have an active plan to introduce us to him face-to-face. But that could change . . . And yes! The wood thrush does represent the Holy Spirit, at least loosely. Good spot!
1) I have to say, with the pride Leonard showed as well as the duke's mention of Lionheart, I had a guess going on that Leo was a prince.
3)He retained vivid memories of being sat upon by the large boy which had not improved with time.
Something about this line just reminded me of Eustace Scrubb from the Chronicles of Narnia, and how very mean he was to everyone at the start. Is there a chance that the Duke reforms later on?
Whoaaaa...! I had completely forgotten this quote:
"Then I think you are a very brave Fool," Una said quietly.
"If I were not a Fool, do you think I could be brave?"
...and I think I inadvertently stole it. At least, I'm pretty sure I read "Heartless" before writing this scene.
“If you were not—such a fool, I might think you were brave.”
“Do you think I would have any bravery,” Tip said, “if I were not a fool?”
Bother it! That is amusing and irritating at once.
@Abigail: I'll just preen and tell myself that it was a completely intentional Literary Nod . . . :) "I've never had another writer offer me a Literary Nod before!" says I, with sparkly-eyed delight.
1. I actually didn't notice it the first time I read the book. The problem with me is, I read a book the first time through very quickly (to get the story-line), then I reread it to get the characters, then I reread it to get small details I missed, then I reread it because the book is so awesome. So I completely missed most of the little tidbits you added into "Heartless" the first time around (but I reread it three times in two weeks, and three or four more times after that, so now I've noticed a lot more.:D). Now I know better and I read your books very very carefully so that I get EVERYTHING the first time. :)
2. I didn't really think of the dragons as anything but dragons the first time around... I thought they would definitely come into the story and burn some stuff down, but I didn't realize how important they were until they actually appeared in the story. And I most certainly didn't hazard any guesses at how they procreated. I guess I just assumed that they would lay eggs or something... the truth was much more disturbing. :P
1. I can't really remember what I thought, but I'm fairly certain I wondered.
2. I was not entirely sure how they would procreate. When I read the back of the book, it sounded like the Dragon wanted Una for his wife, which made me uneasy. Boy, was I wrong!
3. "He's been called the largest man south of Beauclair!"
"As I said, he is quite wealthy..."
"Regarding his girth, not his riches!"
1. I don't think I guess Leonard's identity right away. Sometimes I'm slow, sometimes I'm quick at these things. ha!
2. rumors were intriguing, when I read it the first time, I had connected the dots about the dragon coming for Una, so when the Duke mentions procreation, I was like, What?! What kind of story is this? Ha! I didn't at that time realize the dragon could shapeshift into a man, even though, he did in one of her first dreams. I just didn't remember. But that said, I had no idea how the dragon "procreated" :-)
3. "A sturdy age, practically the prime of life." I love how Nurse is so optimistic on these suitors, trying convince Una.
"All romance seemed to have vanished from life in one fell swoop."
"You make it sound like the descending hordes. How many this time?"
"Have you ever dreamed of one thing for so long, wanted nothing more than to have that dream fulfilled, only to find out that maybe it wasn't what you actually wanted all along?"
..."I believe that's called growing up."
Speaking of literary nods, I think I saw one towards the end of Heartless, but should I wait to reveal what I think until we get there?
1. I did guess Leonard's identity!
2. My first thoughts were...I don't remember, lol. I've read it so many times! But I didn't guess how dragons came to be.
3. I LOVE this line: "Don't be silly," Una said.
"Can't be helped. It's my job."
I adored Leo from the beginning...he's so adorable! But weak...
1) I kind of wondered but was not sure.
2)The way to get new dragons in this book was NOT how I thought it would work.
1)No, I didn't get it. I, too,was wrapped up in enjoying the odiousness of the Duke.
2)I was like, "Ah, so how does he?"
Then it came to me, "He takes actual people and turns them to dragons!!!!"
3)" 'Then I think you are a very brave fool,' Una said quietly.
'If I were not a Fool, do you think I could be so brave?' "
If you answer a question, does it count if it's a day late?
@Rebekah: Absolutely! You can go back and answer an entire week's worth of questions on one day, and it will still count. Just so long as I see your name counted among each days' comments, you'll be included in the name-drawing this weekend. :)
Question and Veiled Rose spoiler warning, wouldn't the Duke have recognized Leonard? After all he did free one of the Duke's "favorite" servants and the Duke seems to have a hateful enough temper not to forget the doer of such a deed. I haven't reread VR yet so I can't remember if Lionheart/Leonard was a jester yet by this point.
1, it's been too long since I first read Heartless to remember my reaction, but the students I'm reading this to did not catch this. Recently we read chapters 29-32 (or somewhere thereabouts) and the kids don't like poor Lionheart.
@Rina: I'll answer here so as to avoid as much spoiling as possible! The Duke DOES actually recognize Leonard. In VEILED ROSE, he catches Leonard within hours of the encounter in the sitting room and is quite irked. He's a lot more cunning than HEARTLESS leads us to believe! (But just as odious.)
Poor Lionheart. I'm sad, but not at all surprised, that your kids aren't liking him! He certainly messes up big time . . .
""Why? She asks me why?" Leonard picked up a handful of acorn caps and started juggling them as he spoke. "Three times," he said, "three times I witnessed the princess yawn last night as I sang. Not once, not twice but three! And yet m'lady asks me why."
"Don't be silly," Una said.
"Can't be helped. It's my job.""
""You snicker at me," he said, shaking a fist at her, "but I know that you are secretly jealous. "Ah!' the lady sighs, 'If only I could wear bells upon my elbows,then my life should be complete!""
Leonard is one of my favorite characters in this series. He is so amusing. =)
1. I don't remember being too surprised by the revelation. I think I was clued in mostly by Leonard's frustration when Una encounter him mopping floors. I thought, "He's taking this very personally". Also, his actions in the sitting room clearly showed his anger towards the duke. Definitely a very odious man but not as dimwitted as I first believed.
2. I thought dragon's procreating simply meant that he was searching for someone to take to his cave for a trophy. You cerainly took the idea of dragons to a whole new level. Very frightening! So excited to hear your thoughts on the Dragon King himself.
Question: This will probably relate to Sunday's post, but could the Dragon have gotten into Oriana's Palace if Una hadn't invited him in? I didn't think so, but I just wanted to make sure.
1. I knew he was something more than a jester, but I did not guess he was prince Lionheart of Southlands.
2. I guess I thought there were some rumors about dragons. Even in the first chapter and ever since dragons have made a small appearance.
3. Definitely the jester's song; "But to his dismay, he was made aware That his suit was unwelcome before her. Our poor Beastly Lout felt her pickling stare 'Cause his stories did certainly bore her." -vs. 2
1. I did catch it, mostly because it was similar to a plot in a movie I've seen.
2. When I was still fairly new to the story my mind went back to the story question at the back cover "THE DRAGON KING SEEKS HIS PRINCESS—WHO DEARS TO STOP HIM?" So you can probably guess what I was thinking.
3. "Ouch! That WAS my foot!"
"No m'lady, you scarcely touched me. You appeared so set on your path, I feared if I didn't speak up, you might walk right on into the stream and drown without noticing."
"Without noticing you or without noticing drowning?"
"Both probably. "
#1 - When I first read it, I think it came as a complete surprise to me that he was the Southlands Prince. But this is a re-read after Veiled Rose and Moonblood, so I know who he is now. :)
#2 - I thought the dragons were the regular, mindless beasts that they are in other stories. I must say I was surprised later in the book!
#3 - Leonard lifted a hand, struck a sour chord on his lute, and cried, "What-ho! A merry bunch you are tonight!" (p. 149)
Post a Comment